Answered jb questions

[Mr. Cubano]

hello i got a few questions that i was wondering.

1st question: About markers
Scenario 1: The round is a normal day, Warden is picked randomly, who starts placing down markers and does not say anything in his microphone. Are the Prisoners obligated to follow the markers anyways? Is the Warden breaking rules? If yes or no, why?
Scenario 2: The round so far went normal, all Prisoners have recently finished the minigame X, but then the Warden places down markers and does not tell Reds to go to them. Are the Prisoners obligated to follow the markers anyways? Is the Warden breaking rules? If yes or no, why?

2nd question: About entering minigames
Scenario: Warden tell players to follow the markers, then he places a marker next to a minigame room, then he opens the door but never tell the players to go inside the game. Yet, Reds go inside and he orders Blus or he himself kills all of the people who went inside, justifying his action by saying he never gave a order for the Reds to go inside. Is it considered a tricky order or not? Why?

 

[Kimmel]

My Thoughts:
None of this is clarified in the rules, this is how I see it atleast.
Question 1
Scenario 1
If you place the marker at the beginning of the round without saying anything, I think it can be a valid order. I think most of the times reds will go the markers. Warden could have just placed it by accident, I think to kill someone for going to the marker however is wrong. It is wardens position to give clear orders, killing someone for going there seems like a trick order, but it isnt a clear enough order to follow.
Just bad wardening
Scenario 2
I think warden should be using his mic more often, and give clear orders.

Question 2
I think my answers above also applies to this, if a warden places a marker next to the door and opens the door most reds would assume to go inside, I think this would be a trick order, maybe just bad wardening,

 

[Jim]

Scenario 1: The round is a normal day, Warden is picked randomly, who starts placing down markers and does not say anything in his microphone. Are the Prisoners obligated to follow the markers anyways? Is the Warden breaking rules? If yes or no, why?

Reds do not have to follow the markers and cannot be killed for following or not following markers. Warden must give clear and concise orders over mic.

Question 2
I think my answers above also applies to this, if a warden places a marker next to the door and opens the door most reds would assume to go inside, I think this would be a trick order, maybe just bad wardening,

Warden must order reds inside of the minigame and killing reds for not going in, or for staying outside in the marker would count as using markers to trick reds which is not allowed.