Declined Add x-1 Medieval mode

[the acheiver]

Hello, I was thinking of asking if you admins could add x-1 Medieval mode server and add any Attack/Defend maps for a melee fight. Like Degroot Keep and other Medieval mode maps cause the x-1 is fun to play with the melees so add Medieval mode maps for Attack/Defend. The server will be x-1 for melees only. So can you do this suggestion?

 

[Chris TCC]

I... don't know what to think of that. Most weapons used in Medieval are stock, or huntsmen, which aren't really x-1 supported weapons, right?
The only weapons I could think of are probably the swords for demoknights.
Maybe I'm wrong, anyone can correct me on this?

 

[the acheiver]

there are many more than this pan crits a lot, the gunslinger crits a many more and the market gardener too, and etc

 

[Chris TCC]

there are many more than this pan crits a lot, the gunslinger crits a many more and the market gardener too, and etc

as far as I know, none of these are affected by x-1 (crits-wise)

 

[the acheiver]

I know about it crit wise but some are powerful

 

[the acheiver]

so did you guys decided if this will be a game mode?

 

[Chris TCC]

Suggestions take time. We need more feedback first. But from the way things look, it won't be accepted - it's at a -2 vote right now.

 

[the acheiver]

But I would like for a game mode of x-1 medieval mode with this and map with it too

 

[Chris TCC]

I don't understand what you want from a x-1 server. Most weapons would be identical to their normal x1 counterparts. The change wouldn't be big enough to warrant an entirely new server.

 

[the acheiver]

the melees that are powerful like market gardener can crit without jumping or the pan and many more

 

[Chris TCC]

market gardener can crit without jumping

that's one.

the pan

unaffected. the pan has no stats to invert.

many more

you gave me one example, I'm still not convinced.

 

[the acheiver]

1. the gloves of running has crits but if you kill someone you lose it

2. the wrap assassin has more damage there

3. the sun on a stick has more damage

4. the amputator which is not good in x-1 kills your teammates

5. the gunslinger has a lot of damage

6. disciplinary action slows you and teammates which might be fun to other players

7. the back scratcher has an over heal but has ez ways to kill

8. the gloves of running is slowing you down and so as the powerjack too

9. kunai makes you lose health if you do a stab

10. the boston basher does a lot of damage and doesn't make players or you bleed


so these are the weapons that I said are fair to play with

 

[seraphina]

This just feels like melee with mostly downgrades, and a few minor upgrades that would get stale really fast. I don't think a couple of extra damage is convincing enough to make a new server to play on.

I don't know much about x-1 but I assume that the gamemode's appeal mostly lies in the shootable weapons, not the melee.

 

[the acheiver]

well then

 

[the acheiver]

I am done then give out if, if cannot be a server then ok decline it then

 

[Chris TCC]

Closing due to the downvotes. Thanks for the suggestion.